Bennington Homes for Sale

Real Estate in Benngington - Carlisle PA

About Bennington

Begin Building the home of your dreams with Gemcraft Homes at Bennington, Carlisle's newest single-family home community! Bennington features 134 homesites with a variety of design and floor plan options including both single-level ranch homes and two-story homes. With options starting in the high $300,000's, Gemcraft Homes offers affordable floor plans that don't sacrifice design or detail. Join our VIP list to get all of the latest information on Bennington today!

Sign up for a free account to receive email alerts whenever new Bennington real estate listings come on the market that match your specific criteria or save your favorite Carlisle real estate listingsThe Dave Hooke Team is your key to Central PA Real Estate.

Search All Bennington Homes for Sale Below

Bennington Models 

To-be-built dream homes! Below are a few of the floor plan options offered at Bennington.

Give us a call, (717) 216-0867, to explore all of the available floor plan options to find your perfect fit.

15 Floor Plans to Choose From and Thousands of Design Options to Meet Every Need!

Photo Gallery


Bennington Homes for Sale May 18, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
6 Properties

Contact Your Carlisle Realtor®

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

About Living in Bennington

The community of Bennington resides in one of Pennsylvania’s safest college towns, Carlisle. This small town is located in the heart of Cumberland Valley County offerings its residents a dense suburban feel with the charm of a small town. Rich in history, this area is full of local businesses, ranging from locally sourced restaurants, breweries, antique stores, artsy shops, and book shops, as there is plenty to do minutes away from this single-home community. 

Bennington is the new community in the heart of Carlisle, PA, and is a phenomenal community offering an array of benefits to homeowners. This borough provides a comfortable lifestyle in one of the safest college towns in Pennsylvania. Bennington is known for its friendly and welcoming atmosphere, with Carlisle offering big-city amenities while keeping with small-town charm. The homesites in this serene neighborhood are spread graciously throughout the community along with vibrant green yards. Beautifully-designed homes include modernized floor plans that are ideal for entertaining accompanied by private and spacious owner’s suites. 

Bennington Schools 

Students residing in the Bennington community fall within the Carlisle Area School District, which is responsible for educating students in this area. Various grade levels are catered to ensure a comprehensive learning experience for all of the district’s students. 

For elementary education, students from Bennington attend Bellaire Elementary School. This elementary school is part of the Carlisle Area School District, providing a strong foundation of learning to foster development. 

When students progress to middle school, they will be enrolled in the Wilson Middle School, located in the Carlisle Area School District, focusing on preparing children to transition to high school. 

The education journey will continue at the high school level where students living in Bennington would attend Carlisle High School. This school provides its students with a wide range of academic programs, preparing them for higher education and the workforce. 

It is important to know that the Carlisle Area School District’s approach to education might have evolved since our last update. If you are looking for accurate and up-to-date information about the Carlisle Area School District. We always recommend contacting the school district directly or visiting the website for current details. 

Near Bennington 

Grocery Store: ALDI— This organic chain store located in Carlisle, PA sells a range of grocery items, meat, and dairy! 

Coffee Shop: Denim Coffee— Located in downtown Carlisle, PA just down from the square, this coffee shop features a full espresso and specialty coffee menu, breakfast sandwiches, panini sandwiches, smoothies, baked goods, UnDone Kombucha, and more! 

Entertainment: Grand Illusion Escape— This escape room center located in Carlisle, PA, has the largest selection of Pennsylvania cider on draft in the world and the family-friendly atmosphere boasts delicious food such as flatbread, salad, and appetizers. And of course, don’t forget the escape rooms set to tease your brain to solve the puzzles to escape. 

Park: Letort Park— This 12-acre recreational park features a playground, a sports field, and a pond with geese and ducks. For children, there is a large-scale 

Dining: Momma Spriggs Restaurant— This restaurant is set in a laid-back venue, offering seasonal American comfort food for meals such as breakfast, lunch, and dinner. 

Fitness center: The Med Gym— This unique exercise training center offers custom assessments and exercise programs for those of all ages, needs, and abilities. Exercise programs are designed to fit the individual. 

Shopping: Castles Commons— This shopping mall located in Carlisle, PA is full of chain restaurants, name-brand stores, and quirky boutiques. 

Interested in all that Bennington has to offer? Welcome to the vibrant community in the heart of Cumberland Valley County. From a welcoming neighborhood to convenient proximity to essential amenities, there are excellent opportunities for newcomers searching for that dense suburban living. Bennington promises many possibilities that await you in this thriving area of Carlisle.

Contact Your Carlisle Realtor.